In this unpretentious pizzeria, the plastic menus and the pizzas—including a dessert version with Nutella—are so authentic that you might almost imagine you’re in the middle of Italy. The true highlight, however, is the cocktail bar modeled after the New York speakeasies from the 1920s. The bar can only be reached through a walk-in freezer and lives up to its promise: It offers more than 80 brands of whiskey, sophisticated cocktails, jazz music, and a smoking room.